Butter Cheese
Please note about pricing: our online store is still under construction, and prices are subject to change when you visit our store. If you want to confirm pricing before you visit, please call us at 315-536-0836.
$4.59
* Contains: Milk.
Butter Cheese, often known as Amish Butter Cheese, is a rich, creamy delight that offers a smooth texture and mild, buttery flavor perfect for any cheese lover. Made from high-quality cow’s milk, this Havarti-style cheese is naturally yellow in color and rindless, making it not only delicious but visually appealing on any cheese platter. Its luxurious, velvety consistency and subtle taste make it a versatile staple in both everyday meals and gourmet dishes.
Ideal for slicing, melting, or grilling, Butter Cheese is an excellent choice for sandwiches, paninis, burgers, and wraps. It also melts beautifully, making it a delicious addition to hot dishes like casseroles, macaroni and cheese, or even fondue. As a snack, it pairs wonderfully with fresh fruits, cured meats, or a glass of crisp white wine.
Loved by kids and adults alike, Butter Cheese brings comfort and indulgence to the table with every bite. Whether served at a gathering or enjoyed on a quiet afternoon, its mellow, satisfying flavor makes it a go-to cheese for every occasion.



