Oak Leaf Bakery

icon - fresh-bread

Fresh Flavors

icon - recipes

Amish & Mennonite Recipes

icon - homemade-bread

Local Finger Lakes Items

Featured Bakery Items

Visit Us
View Specials

Enjoy A Variety of Handmade Baked Goods Focused on Quality and Taste

It doesn’t matter if you want to satisfy your sweet tooth or pick up a few staples for your next meal, our well-stocked bakery has the times and flavors you want and need!

  • Fry pies

  • Homemade frozen cookie dough

  • White bread

  • Cranberry orange scones

  • Cinnamon rolls

  • Sticky buns

  • Banana bread

  • Whoopie pies

  • And much more!

Visit Us
View Specials

Experience A Different
Kind Of Bakery

  • 1

    Visit Us

    Stop by our store to see everything we offer, grab a bite to eat, or taste some samples.

  • 2

    Experience The Difference

    From wide aisles to clean restrooms, enjoy a different food shopping experience.

  • 3

    Purchase & Enjoy

    Taste the difference with fresh & high-quality foods!

“Extremely friendly staff. They were so helpful regarding questions I had about spices. And loved the variety of baked goods!”

- Anne

“So many wonderful items to choose from. Fresh baked goods, easy bake frozen items, bulk items and your regular shopping items all in one place.”

- Ashley

“Incredible regional representation. Delicious baked goods, bulk foods and an array of products that will appeal to all.”

- Eugene

What You Can Expect When You Visit Our Bakery

With 40+ years and 3 generations of bulk food experience, our goal is to make food shopping enjoyable and stress-free.

When you shop with us, you get to enjoy…

When you shop with us, you get to enjoy…

  • Cheerful staff who willingly help you
  • Made-from-scratch items
  • Amish & Mennonite recipes passed down several generations
  • Large variety of bulk & specialty food items, including foods with minimal preservatives & additives
  • Local Finger Lakes food, dairy, and craft items
  • Unique items not found in larger grocery chains
  • Clean store with wide aisles, clean restrooms, and peaceful music
  • A large outdoor children’s playground

We would love to meet you.
Stop by today!

Visit Us
View Specials

Visit Your Local Bakery In The NY Finger Lakes

Are you tired of baked goods that have mediocre flavors or don’t fully satisfy your sweet tooth?

At our Oak Hill Bakery, our items are fresh, homemade, and based on Amish & Mennonite recipes passed down through several generations.

Stop by today and taste the difference today!

Visit Us
View Specials