About Us

It all started in 1983 when the founders, Amos & Fannie Stoltzfus, noticed a need for a local bulk and specialty food store in the Yates County area.

When they started selling products out of their home, they didn’t know that 40+ years and 3 generations later, Oak Hill would be a staple to the greater Finger Lakes region.

To see our full history and timeline, please click here.

From fresh foods in the cafe to well-stocked shelves in the store (and don’t forget the summer chicken BBQ!), Oak Hill has become famous for its fresh flavors and friendly customer service.

Today, Oak Hill is owned by Amos & Fannie’s daughter and her husband, Phil and LaReta Riehl. Together with several of their children and hundreds of valued local employees, Oak Hill continues to grow and serve both the local and greater Central NY communities.

Stop by today to taste and experience the difference. We would love to meet and serve you!

Reihl Family 2024-2

The Riehl
Family

Summer-Picnic12-scaled

The Oak Hill
Team

Our Purpose:

We are a specialty food store providing quality foods in a positive and friendly environment.

We Look For Ways to Improve the Lives of Everyone We Serve:

icon - employees

Employees

All employees will be treated with dignity in every conversation and every circumstance. We will train and equip them to be efficient and competent, always helping them to advance in their personal and professional lives.

icon - food-donation

Customers

We will improve the lives of our customers by providing unique and quality products they look forward to sharing with their friends and family.

icon - suppliers

Suppliers

We will establish mutually beneficial relationships with our suppliers so they can grow and improve with us.