Skip to content
315-536-0836
Hours: 8AM - 6PM
3173 Route 14A, Penn Yan, NY 14527
Search Our Store...
Search
Bakery
Cafe
Oak Leaf Cafe
Menu
Catering Brochure
Bulk Foods
Deli
Canopy Roasters
On Sale
Specials
Bakery Sales
Deli Sales
Bulk Food Sales
About
Contact Us
Visit Us
About Us
History
Summer at Oak Hill
×
Bakery
Cafe
Oak Leaf Cafe
Menu
Catering Brochure
Bulk Foods
Deli
Canopy Roasters
On Sale
Specials
Bakery Sales
Deli Sales
Bulk Food Sales
About
Contact Us
Visit Us
About Us
History
Summer at Oak Hill
Bakery
Cafe
Oak Leaf Cafe
Menu
Catering Brochure
Bulk Foods
Deli
Canopy Roasters
On Sale
Specials
Bakery Sales
Deli Sales
Bulk Food Sales
About
Contact Us
Visit Us
About Us
History
Summer at Oak Hill
×
Bakery
Cafe
Oak Leaf Cafe
Menu
Catering Brochure
Bulk Foods
Deli
Canopy Roasters
On Sale
Specials
Bakery Sales
Deli Sales
Bulk Food Sales
About
Contact Us
Visit Us
About Us
History
Summer at Oak Hill
Pies
Home
/
Bakery
/ Pies
Search Our Store...
Search
Showing 1–52 of 59 results
Default sorting
Sort by popularity
Sort by average rating
Sort by latest
Sort by price: low to high
Sort by price: high to low
Apple Crumb Pie
$
9.99
Apple Crumb Pie Slice
$
1.75
Apple Pie
$
9.99
Banana Creme Pie
$
10.99
Black Raspberry Pie
$
9.99
Blueberry Pie
$
10.99
Cherry Crumb Pie
$
9.99
Cherry Pie
$
9.99
Chocolate Cream Pie
$
10.99
Chocolate Mint Pie
$
10.99
Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie
$
10.99
Chocolate Raspberry Pie
$
10.99
Coconut Cream Pie
$
11.99
Elderberry Pie
$
9.99
Fresh Peach Pie
$
9.99
Fresh Strawberry Pie
$
10.99
Grape Crumb Pie
$
9.99
Grape Pie
$
12.99
Harvest Fruit Pie
$
9.99
Keuka Fruit Pie
$
9.99
Lemon Meringue Pie
$
10.99
Lime Pie
$
10.99
Lime Pie Slice
$
1.75
Mince Meat Pie
$
16.99
Mini Apple Crumb Pie
$
3.29
Mini Apple Pie
$
3.29
Mini Black Raspberry Pie
$
3.29
Mini Blueberry Pie
$
3.29
Mini Bumbleberry Pie
$
3.29
Mini Cherry Crumb Pie
$
3.29
Mini Cherry Pie
$
3.29
Mini Coconut Cream Pie
$
1.99
Mini Elderberry Pie
$
3.29
Mini Fresh Peach Pie
$
3.29
Mini Fresh Strawberry Pie
$
3.29
Mini Grape Crumb Pie
$
1.99
Mini Grape Pie
$
3.29
Mini Keuka Fruit Pie
$
3.29
Mini Lemon Meringue Pie
$
3.29
Mini Mince Meat Pie
$
3.49
Mini Pecan Pie
$
3.49
Mini Pumpkin Pie
$
3.29
Mini Red Raspberry Pie
$
3.29
Mini Rhubarb Pie
$
3.29
Mini Shoo-Fly Pie
$
1.99
Mini Strawberry Pie
$
1.99
Mini Strawberry Rhubarb Pie
$
3.29
Peach Pie
$
8.99
Peanut Butter Pie
$
10.99
Pecan Pie
$
12.99
Pumpkin Pie
$
10.99
Red Raspberry Pie
$
9.99
1
2
Next »
